Apex Court

Pionee – Prez Reference on 2G to meet ‘review plea’ end: Prashant

Prez Reference on 2G to meet ‘review plea’ end: Prashant
Tuesday, 05 June 2012 00:19
 Pioneer News Service | New Delh

The Government’s attempt to question the auction of 2G spectrum through a Presidential Reference has come under cloud with the petitioner in the case accusing the Centre of “forum shopping”.

In its response to the reference heard by a five-judge Constitution bench in Supreme Court, the Centre for Public Interest Litigation (CPIL) has leveled the charge against Centre of pleading the “same” grounds which failed to convince a two-judge bench that heard the review petition. Upset over the court’s refusal to entertain the said grounds, the Centre withdrew its review plea on May 10.

Raising a preliminary objection against entertaining of the Presidential Reference, CPIL counsel Prashant Bhushan said, “Government has indulged in forum shopping by filing a Presidential reference raising the same issues as were raised in… Continue reading

FC – Telenor says deferred payment for spectrum to help new players

By PTI May 31 2012 , New Delhi
Norwegian firm Telenor today said it may not participate in the upcoming spectrum auction in case the government does not offer the option of deferred payment for the airwaves.
Citing that fund availability for the telecom sector was becoming increasingly difficult, Telenor Executive Vice President and Head of Region Asia Sigve Brekke said deferred payment would help new operators like Uninor invest in spectrum and network expansion.

“Especially for us as a new comer, there is no funding available for us in India to pay for spectrum … You need at least 4 blocks or 5 MHz to be able to operate, so the upfront payment problem is larger for us than incumbents … (if) we need to use the cash to buy spectrum, we will not be able to expand,” Brekke told reporters here.

The Supreme Court had in February cancelled… Continue reading

Call to redial

The best thing for the Government to do is to auction all available spectrum resulting from cancellation of the tainted licences.

 

The Telecom Commission has asked the industry regulator to give a complete “analysis” of the impact of its 2G spectrum pricing proposals on consumer tariffs, viability and continued attractiveness of the sector for investors, and revenues to the Government. That, in a sense, amounts to the Government wanting the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) to revise its recommendations on auction of airwaves made last month. These have been criticised by many, quite justifiably, as muzzling competition. TRAI had suggested selling only 5 MHz of spectrum, enough to accommodate just one additional player to operate in each of the country’s 22 telecom circles. Considering the context in which the recommendations were made — in pursuance of the Supreme Court’s order cancelling 122 licenses held by eight operators —… Continue reading

EGoM to meet on June 5 for fixing spectrum price

PTI
New Delhi, May 28, 2012

 

An Empowered Group of Ministers (EGoM), headed by finance minister Pranab Mukherjee, will meet on June 5 to decide on the base price for the much-awaited auction of telecom spectrum.
“The EGoM will meet on June 5,” department of telecom secretary R Chandrashekhar told reporters in New

Delhi.

 

The Telecom Commission (TC), which met here last week, left the decision on the high-powered ministerial panel of fixing the price of spectrum to be auctioned, as necessitated by the cancellation of 122 2G licences by the Supreme Court.

 

It has asked sectoral regulator Trai to conduct an analysis of the impact of spectrum price on tariff if it is passed on and in case it is absorbed, then what is the effect on companies’ businesses, viability and return on investment.

 

The detailed analysis, along with Trai recommendations, would be presented to… Continue reading

I will file complaint in Aircel-Maxis deal: Swamy tells court

NEW DELHI: Janata Party president Subramanian Swamy today told a Delhi court hearing the 2G spectrum case that he will file a private complaint in the case relating to Aircel-Maxis deal.

He told Special CBI Judge O P Saini that the CBI is investigating the Aircel-Maxis deal but he wants to file an additional complaint in the case over which he had earlier leveled allegations against Home Minister P Chidambaram.

CBI is probing the alleged role of former Telecom Minister Dayanidhi Maran in the Aircel-Maxis deal. The Court posted hearing in the case for August 25.

Swamy had earlier told the Supreme Court, which is hearing the case, that the CBI probe into the Aircel-Maxis deal was focused only on Maran’s role in arm-twisting Aircel’s owner to sell his stake to the Malaysian firm Maxis.

“My matter is partially different from the CBI’s case. In the Aircel-Maxis matter, there is… Continue reading

EGoM to decide spectrum price for auction: Telecom Commission

An Empowered Group of Ministers (EGoM) may early next month decide on the base price for auction of telecom spectrum after an inter-ministerial panel presents pros and cons of accepting sectoral regulator Trai’s steep reserve price.

The Telecom Commission (TC), which had earlier this week fixed modalities of the spectrum auction necessitated by the cancellation of 122 2G licences by Supreme Court, deliberated on the base price suggested by Trai.

However, it has decided to leave the decision upon Finance Minister Pranab Mukherjee-headed panel.

“The TC took note of reserve price which Trai has recommended and it (TC) felt that an analysis needs to be made and presented to EGoM on the impact of spectrum price on certain parameters that have been worked out,” TC Chairman and DoT secretary R Chandrashekhar told reporters here.

He added that analysis would be carried out by Trai keeping in mind that a balance… Continue reading

EGoM to decide 2G base price in June

The highest decision-making body in the telecom department, the Telecom Commission (TC), on Saturday left it to the empowered group of ministers (EGoM) headed by finance minister Pranab Mukherjee to take a decision on the base price for the auction of 2G spectrum.
All major telecom players, including Bharti Airtel, Vodafone, Idea, Reliance and Tata, were against the high base price recommended by telecom regulator Trai. The EGoM is expected to meet early in June to take decisions on the 2G spectrum auction, necessitated due to the Supreme Court cancelling 122 licences issued by former communications minister A. Raja in 2008. The apex court had directed Trai to frame new auction rules and the government to complete the spectrum sale by August 31.
The TC has asked Trai to submit before the EGoM an analysis of the impact of the proposed spectrum pricing on the industry.
“The TC took note… Continue reading

2G scam | Swamy will file complaint in Aircel-Maxis deal

New Delhi: Janata Party president Subramanian Swamy on Saturday told a Delhi court hearing the 2G spectrum case that he will file a private complaint in the case relating to Aircel-Maxis deal. He told Special CBI Judge O P Saini that the CBI is investigating the Aircel-Maxis deal but he wants to file an additional complaint in the case over which he had earlier levelled allegations against home minister P Chidambaram.

 

Janata Party president Subramanian Swamy

Janata Party president Subramanian Swamy

 

CBI is probing the alleged role of former telecom minister Dayanidhi Maran in the Aircel-Maxis deal.

 

The court posted hearing in the case for 25 August. Swamy had earlier told the Supreme Court, which is hearing the case, that the CBI probe into the Aircel-Maxis deal was focused only on Maran’s role in arm-twisting Aircel’s owner to sell his stake to the Malaysian firm Maxis.

“My matter is partially different from… Continue reading

Idea Cellular wants 2G spectrum reserve price fixed at 2008 rates

Idea Cellular has urged the telecom ministry to ensure that the reserve price for 2G spectrum be fixed at 2008 rates and not as per the recommendations of the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI).

Referring to the regulator’s recommendations, Idea Cellular – part of the Aditya Birla group – noted they were in gross violation of the Supreme Court directive. The company said the entire spectrum attached to the 122 licences cancelled by the apex court should be put up for auction.

”The (court) order does not lend itself to mutilation by any reduction from 122, in the number of licenses to be auctioned,” said the letter to the ministry. ”Equally, the order does not lend itself to diversion of the spectrum attached to the quashed 122 licences to any one, other than the new licence auction winners.”

The reserve price should be the price paid in 2008, plus… Continue reading

2G spectrum auction: CDMA lobby asks Kapil Sibal to ignore pricing panel report

New Delhi: The industry body of CDMA operators has asked telecom minister Kapil Sibal to ignore suggestions made by JS Deepak, the government-appointed auction overseer, specific to telcos using dual-technology spectrum.

Association of Unified Telecom Service Providers of India or Auspi, that represents companies like Reliance Communications, Tata Teleservices and Sistema Shyam, has written to Sibal that targeting dual-technology operators to pay up for spectrum at a market-determined price would be ‘illegal and contrary to the policies of the level-playing field’ in a communication to the minister last week, seen by ET.

Auspi said that dual-technology mobile permits were not cancelled by the Supreme Court, and thus the original price they paid of 1,659 crore, as discovered in an airwave auction in 2001 was fair. On February 2, the Indian apex court rolled back 122 licences awarded in the controversial 2008 allocations.

The lobby said the matter was sub judice… Continue reading

Follow us