TRAI

HT – 2G auction: DoT’s letters to TRAI raises eyebrows

2G auction: DoT’s letters to TRAI raises eyebrows
Manoj Gairola, Hindustan Times
New Delhi, June 05, 2012

The Department of Telecommunications’ (DoT) letter to the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) on the impact of spectrum pricing on telecom tariffs, for the third time, has raised eyebrows. According to section 11 of the TRAI Act, 1997, the government can ask the regulator only once to
reconsider its recommendations.

On April 23, the regulator first submitted its recommendations on spectrum auction to the government. After reconsidering the points raised by the government, it submitted a fresh set of recommendations on May 13.

On May 14, Rahul Khullar took over as the new TRAI chairman from JS Sarma. Now, the government has again sought the telecom regulator’s views on the impact of pricing on tariffs.

According to section 11 (d) of TRAI Act: “….if the Central government having considered that recommendations of… Continue reading

PTI/IANS update

JPC Unlikely to Call Former Ministers on 2G Issue
PTI | New Delhi | Jun 05, 2012
The Joint Parliamentary Committee is unlikely to call former ministers, including main accused A Raja, in connection with the 2G spectrum scam as it wants to prune the number of witnesses and prepare its report by September.

There is an overwhelming view in the JPC, which has already got two extensions, that there was no need to call the former ministers as witnesses as enough material was available in the form of documents and presentations by officials to prepare its report, sources said.

The JPC had earlier decided to call all former Telecom Ministers, including Raja, before it in connection with the probe into the high-profile scam.

There were also demands within the Committee for calling Home Minister P Chidambaram in view of certain allegations against him in the spectrum allocation of 2008… Continue reading

HBL – 2G pricing: Telecom panel to present two options to Ministers’ group

THOMAS K THOMAS
NEW DELHI, JUNE 1: The spectrum pricing formula suggested by both TRAI and an internal DoT committee will be presented to the Empowered Group of Minister for a final decision.
While TRAI had proposed Rs 18,000 crore as the reserve price for 5 Mhz spectrum, the DoT panel had proposed a 17 per cent higher fee.
The Telecom Commission will also present two options for deciding the quantity of spectrum to be sold.
A minimum of eight blocks each of 1.25 Mhz may be put up for auction in all service areas after reserving for re-farming.
In addition, a provision may also be inserted to make available another three blocks of 1.25 Mhz to meet the requirement of new entrants.
The second option is to put all spectrum available on the block, which includes 55 Mhz spectrum to be vacated by the Defence, according to the Minutes… Continue reading

HBL – No funds to pay upfront for 2G spectrum: Uninor

OUR BUREAU
Uninor on Thursday said that it will be almost impossible to participate in the upcoming 2G spectrum auction if its not allowed to pay the bid amount staggered over a period of 10 years.
 
While TRAI had recommended staggered payment, the Government is not in favour of allowing it.
“The challenge arising from upfront payments is not one of unwillingness but inability. Uninor has concluded informal discussions with several Indian banks. No bank is willing to lend such amounts upfront to a new operator to fund the spectrum costs,” Uninor said.
 
” As a new operator, Uninor also does not have a positive cash flow to fund these costs. Further, upfront payments will create an unequal impact for new operators since in the best case scenario, a new operator will need to pay double the amount upfront to continue operations,” it said.
 
The company, majority… Continue reading

HBL – Proposed 2G reserve price won’t impact industry profitabil​ity: TRAI

THOMAS K THOMAS

The Telecom Regulatory Authority of India has told Department of Telecom that the proposed reserve price for 2G spectrum auction will not have any adverse impact on the industry.
The telecom regulator has said that that the recommended price ensures that the full value of the spectrum is realised to the Government. TRAI has estimated the value to be about Rs 7 lakh crore.
“This will not compromise the profitability of the industry, or adversely affect the affordability to the consumer,” the TRAI said in its response to a joint letter written by four CEOs of telecom companies.
The CEOs had written to the Government on May 2 claiming that the TRAI proposals will hit the operators’ revenues. “EBITDA and Return on Capital Employed show a very healthy and increasing trend over the next 20 years. The Internal Rate of Return are also robust,” the TRAI has… Continue reading

HBL – 2G pricing: TRAI rebuts telcos’ claims

THOMAS K. THOMAS
The Telecom Regulatory Authority of India has refuted claims by telecom companies that its 2G spectrum recommendations were flawed. In a point-by-point rebuttal to the joint letter sent by CEOs of four telecom companies, TRAI said the proposed reserve price will not affect the industry’s health.
“EBITDA and Return on Capital Employed show a very healthy and increasing trend over the next 20 years. The Internal Rate of Return is also robust,” TRAI has told the Department of Telecom, in reply to the joint letter from the telecom companies.
This assumes significance because the Telecom Commission has asked the regulator for a detailed analysis on the impact of the proposed base price on the industry.

HBL – New TRAI chief defends 2G spectrum pricing at JPC

Our Bureau

 

The new Chairman of Telecom Regulatory Authority of India on Tuesday defended its 2G spectrum proposals at a meeting of the Joint Parliamentary Committee.

 

This assumes significance given that the Telecom Commission has asked TRAI to give an analysis on the impact of its pricing proposal. Telecom companies, which are protesting against the TRAI proposals, were hoping for a review.

 

But at today’s JPC meeting TRAI contested the telecom companies’ arguments that if implemented, the recommendations would result in increase in mobile charges. The TRAI Chairman, Dr Rahul Khullar, and former chairman, Dr J.S. Sarma, appeared before the panel.

 

The JPC Chairman, Mr P.C. Chacko, told Business Line that TRAI’s presentation on the new set of recommendations will continue in the next meeting of the JPC.

 

“We are trying for a presentation by another former chairman of TRAI. Members are yet… Continue reading

OutlookIndia – TRAI Defends Recommendations on 2G Before JPC

PTI | New Delhi | May 29, 2012

 

Telecom regulator TRAI today defended the steep minimum price for auction of 2G spectrum saying the technology has undergone a “sea change” since 2008 and assured that consumers would not be affected much as they will have to pay a maximum of five paisa extra per call.

Appearing before Joint Parliamentary Committee (JPC), Telecom Regulatory Authority of India chief Rahul Khullar and his predecessor J S Sarma are learnt to have defended the recommendation to auction 2G spectrum at a base price of Rs 3,622 crore for a megahertz of spectrum at pan-India level which is around 10 times higher than the price for 2G licences in 2008.

The recommendation was made when Sarma was heading TRAI.

On the issue of its impact on the consumers, TRAI officials said since the licences are valid for 20 years, it will have… Continue reading

Call to redial

The best thing for the Government to do is to auction all available spectrum resulting from cancellation of the tainted licences.

 

The Telecom Commission has asked the industry regulator to give a complete “analysis” of the impact of its 2G spectrum pricing proposals on consumer tariffs, viability and continued attractiveness of the sector for investors, and revenues to the Government. That, in a sense, amounts to the Government wanting the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) to revise its recommendations on auction of airwaves made last month. These have been criticised by many, quite justifiably, as muzzling competition. TRAI had suggested selling only 5 MHz of spectrum, enough to accommodate just one additional player to operate in each of the country’s 22 telecom circles. Considering the context in which the recommendations were made — in pursuance of the Supreme Court’s order cancelling 122 licenses held by eight operators —… Continue reading

India calls for review of 2G auction prices

India’s Telecom Commission will ask the country’s regulator to review its decision to recommend steep base prices for India’s forthcoming 2G auctions, reports Reuters.

Speaking to reporters over the weekend, the Commission chair, R.Chandrashekhar, urged the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) to study “the impact of this spectrum price on the tariffs if this entire impact is passed on [and] the impact on the investments, viability and the return on the investments.”

TRAI has recommended a base price for a nationwide 1800MHz licence at INR36.22 billion (US$689.6 million) – over ten times higher than the prices set in a 2008 auction for the same airwaves.

The Indian operator community has criticised the high base price and limited number of slots proposed by the regulator.

On Friday, the Commission said that at least 10MHz of spectrum should be made available in each service area, double the 5MHz recommended by… Continue reading

Follow us